Skip to main content
  • Developers
  • Learning Hub
    • Learning Hub Developers Price. Buy. Download. Try.
    medical_Qa_transparent_2-1

    Ensuring Safety and Saving Lives:
    A Complete Guide to Software Testing in the Medical Device Industry


    Who is this guide for:     Developers, QA testers, and QA professionals

    What you’ll get from it: this guide aims to clarify the regulatory requirements, challenges and best practices in medical device software testing – and give you some tips on how to improve your testing processes.

     

    Download this guide as pdf

    Software testing in the medical device industry is a critical aspect that can make the difference between life and death. Testing ensures that devices work as intended, are safe to use, and meet regulatory requirements.

    In this guide, we'll take a deep dive into everything you need to know about software testing in the medical device industry.

     

    The Software Testing Process in the Medical Device Industry

    The software testing process in the medical device industry is no different from standard software development testing processes and involves several stages:

    1. Planning

    Planning is a vital step in testing as it establishes a foundation for a successful cycle. It involves defining the scope, identifying test cases, and developing a test plan. This ensures a structured and efficient testing process that maximizes the chances of delivering a high-quality product.

    2. Design

    During this stage, skilled testers meticulously design tailored test cases and scenarios to accurately reflect the system under scrutiny. They carefully examine every aspect of the software, identify potential vulnerabilities, and devise strategies to thoroughly explore every nook and cranny, ensuring its robustness and reliability.

    3. Execution

    Skilled testers execute designed test cases and scenarios to uncover potential bugs or glitches in the system. With expertise, they navigate through the software, checking for any anomalies or inconsistencies. Each bug they uncover contributes to improving the product's quality and crafting a reliable solution.

    4. Reporting

    Reporting is a crucial step in testing, where testers document and communicate defects and issues. Detailed reports serve as a valuable resource for developers, enabling them to promptly address identified issues. Testers uncover flaws and offer insights for improvement, contributing to the continuous enhancement of the product and delivering an exceptional user experience.

    5. Verification and Validation

    This crucial stage of the software development process is dedicated to ensuring that all the identified issues have been successfully addressed and resolved. It is a thorough process that involves conducting rigorous tests and assessments to verify the effectiveness of the fixes implemented. By engaging in this vital step, we can confidently guarantee that the software or system is now in its optimal state performing flawlessly.

    Types of Software Testing in Medical Device Industry

    QA_icon_ContinuousAutomation
    Functional Testing

    Checks if the software functions as expected.

     

     

    Integration Testing
    Integration Testing

    Tests how different parts of the software work together.

     

     

    Usability Testing
    Usability Testing

    Ensures that the software is easy to use and understand.

     

     

     

    Performance Testing
    Performance Testing

    Test how the software performs under different conditions.

     

     

    Security Testing
    Security Testing

    Ensures that the software is secure and protected against unauthorized access.

     

     

    Regulatory Requirements for Software Testing in the Medical Device Industry

    The regulatory requirements for software testing in the medical device industry ensure that devices are safe to use, both for the people operating them and the patients being operated on. Let’s take a look at some global and US-specific regulations that apply to many multinational medical device manufacturers. 

    FDA regulations 

    The U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has several regulations that specifically address software testing for medical devices. These regulations ensure that medical device software is safe, effective, and reliable, and the results are generally submitted to the agency.

    One important regulation is the FDA's Guidance for the Content of Premarket Submissions for Software Contained in Medical Devices. This guidance outlines the information that should be included in premarket submissions for medical device software, including details on the software's intended use, device hazard analysis, and testing protocols.

    Another key regulation is the FDA's General Principles of Software Validation, which provides guidance on validating software for use in medical devices. The regulation covers topics such as the software development life cycle, documentation, and testing methods.

    In addition to these regulations, the FDA has specific guidance on software changes to existing medical devices. This guidance outlines the processes that medical device manufacturers should follow when making changes to software that is already on the market.

     

     

    medical-device-iStock-844400636-580x358

     

     

     

    Newsletter_Image_Two_Cols_medical

     

    ISO 14971 

    ISO 14971 is an international standard that outlines the requirements for risk management in medical devices. It is designed to help manufacturers of medical devices identify and manage potential risks associated with their products throughout their entire lifecycle, from design and development to production, distribution, and use.

    When it comes to medical device software testing, ISO 14971 plays a crucial role. Software is often a critical component of medical devices, and it can introduce additional risks that must be managed. Therefore, manufacturers must perform software testing to identify any potential risks and ensure that the software is safe and effective for its intended use.

    ISO 14971 provides a framework for risk management that can be applied to medical device software testing. It requires manufacturers to identify and assess risks associated with the software, determine the acceptable level of risk, and develop and implement strategies to mitigate any identified risks.

    IEC 62304

    IEC 62304 is an international standard that outlines the requirements for developing medical device software. It is a comprehensive standard that covers the entire software development life cycle, from planning to retirement, for medical device software.

    The standard guides software development processes, documentation requirements, and software validation and verification. It’s designed to ensure that medical device software is developed safely and effectively and meets the regulatory requirements of various countries.

    Regarding medical device software testing, the IEC 62304 standard requires that software testing be performed throughout the development life cycle to verify that the software meets its intended use and design requirements. Testing activities should include requirements-based testing, functional testing, and risk-based testing.

    Additionally, the standard requires that medical device software be validated to ensure that it is safe, effective, and meets its intended use. This includes testing the software's final form in the actual operating environment to demonstrate that it meets its intended purpose.

     

     

    Medical COTS WP LP

     

    Get Your Hands on This Guide in PDF Format for In-Depth Reading

    Dive into the depths of this comprehensive guide in PDF format to truly immerse yourself in the topic. Uncover and broaden your understanding of software testing in the medical device industry.

    Download this guide as pdf

    Try out our Quality Assurance Tools at No Cost

    Discover the power of our QA tools with a complimentary trial of Squish for effortless GUI test automation, Coco for comprehensive code coverage, and Test Center for impeccable result management, reporting, and traceability.

    Get a free trial

    Challenges in Software Testing in the Medical Device Industry

    Security testing

    Security testing for healthcare faces significant challenges. The first hurdle lies in the intricate nature of healthcare software, which often comprises numerous layers of functionality. Its complexity poses a formidable obstacle to identifying security vulnerabilities since it becomes arduous to predict and reproduce interactions between components like patient portals and electronic health records.

     

    Privacy and regulatory concerns

    Another challenge stems from restricted access to live patient data. Concerns surrounding privacy and regulatory requirements make obtaining actual patient data for testing a daunting feat. Consequently, conducting tests in real-world scenarios becomes problematic, necessitating additional measures to safeguard the security and privacy of patient information during the testing phase.

    The burdensome task of complying with regulations adds further layers of complexity and constraints to security testing in healthcare. Healthcare software must adhere to many regulations and standards governing data security and privacy, such as HIPAA, GDPR, and PIPEDA. Meeting these regulatory requirements can amplify the common challenges faced during testing.

     

    Integration with other systems 

    Moreover, medical software frequently needs to integrate with various other systems, including other devices and hospital management systems. This integration can introduce vulnerabilities, demanding meticulous testing to ensure the overall system's security. 

     

    User error or unexpected use cases

    Lastly, the diverse user base of healthcare software, including healthcare providers, patients, and administrative staff, presents unexpected scenarios that may not have been adequately anticipated during the software's design and development. This means testing must encompass a comprehensive range of user scenarios to guarantee the software's security and reliability in real-world usage.

     

    Webinars on Quality Assurance in Safety-Critical Industries

    • Combining Static and Dynamic Testing
    • Benefits of Static Code Analysis
    • Elevate Your Quality Assurance With Automated Testing

    From Erosion to Excellence: Combining Static and Dynamic Testing to Do No Harm

    As software development cycles become shorter, it’s increasingly important to ensure that developers and testers don’t inadvertently introduce errors or compromise software quality. Combining static and dynamic testing is an effective way to minimize software erosion caused by short-term requirements.


    Watch the Webinar

    Enhancing Software Quality with Static Code Analysis

    Static code analysis acts as an early quality barrier in the CI pipeline, detecting code patterns that lead to bugs and unnecessary complexity.

    We will discuss the unique insights it provides and its role in enabling developers to produce higher-quality commits. With static code analysis, industry-standard rulesets like MISRA, AUTOSAR, and CERT are easier to implement, ensuring high-quality source code and the best coding practices in safety-critical industries.

    Watch the Webinar

     

    Elevate Your Quality Assurance With Automated Testing

    Learn about the advantages of transitioning from manual to automated software testing.

    To stay competitive in today’s market, companies need effective ways to deliver high-quality software at an accelerated pace while minimizing errors and reducing costs. This webinar will explore how automated testing empowers development teams to streamline their testing efforts through enhanced test coverage and boost overall productivity.

    Watch the webinar

    Best Practices for Software Testing for Medical Devices

    Following best practices when building, testing and launching software helps ensure your organization stays ahead of the curve and can bring new products to market faster. Specifically regarding testing in the medical device industry, below are a few best practices to keep in mind when creating a testing protocol.

    1. Use a risk-based approach
    2. Ensure sufficient code coverage: 
    3. Ensure traceability
    4. Automate testing
    5. Enable collaboration

     

    Related resources on best practices in software testing:

    Download a beginner's guide to software testing

    medical-software-testing-1

     

    Why Automated Testing is the Best Choice for Medical Device Software Testing 

    Automated testing brings several advantages when it comes to testing software in medical devices. Let's take a look at why it is essential in this context:

    1. Precision and consistency: Automated tests follow predefined scripts, ensuring accurate and consistent execution. This eliminates human errors that can occur during manual testing. In medical devices, precision and consistency are crucial for ensuring the software's safety and effectiveness.

    2. Efficiency and speed: Automated tests can be executed faster than manual tests, saving time and resources. Medical devices undergo rigorous testing requirements, and automating the process enables faster feedback cycles. This allows developers to identify and address issues promptly, speeding up the overall development and release process.

    3. Test coverage: Medical devices often have complex functionalities and must comply with various regulations and standards. Automated testing helps achieve higher test coverage by executing a large number of tests in less time. It enables comprehensive testing of different scenarios, inputs, and edge cases, ensuring thorough validation of the software. Combined with a code coverage tool (like our Coco), you can be sure that both your code and test coverage exceed requirements.

    4. Repeatability and reproducibility: Automated tests can be executed repeatedly and consistently, providing the ability to reproduce test scenarios. This is crucial for validating the reliability and stability of medical device software. Test results can be easily compared across different runs, making identifying deviations or issues easier.

    5. Regression testing: Software updates or modifications in medical devices must be thoroughly tested to ensure that existing functionalities are not affected. Automated testing excels in regression testing by quickly rerunning a comprehensive set of tests to verify unchanged aspects of the software. This helps prevent the reintroduction of previously resolved issues and ensures the system's overall integrity. Some automated testing tools, like Squish, if implemented well in your development efforts, can identity regressions early on in the development process. 

    6. Documentation and auditing: Automated testing generates detailed logs and reports, providing comprehensive testing process documentation. This aids in compliance with regulatory requirements and facilitates auditing. Tracking and analysing test results, ideally in a centralised test management platform like Test Center, are essential for medical devices to meet the necessary standards and regulations.

     

    While automated testing offers numerous benefits, it's important to note that it should be complemented with manual testing techniques. Certain aspects, such as user experience, usability, and visual inspection, may still require some human intervention. As such, a combination of automated and manual testing provides the most effective approach to ensure the safety and reliability of medical device software.

     

    Related resources on automated and manual software testing: 

    Conclusion

    Software testing is critical in the medical device industry to ensure patient safety and device efficacy. The testing process involves planning, designing, executing, reporting and verifying the software. Different types of testing, such as functional, integration, usability, performance, and security testing, are conducted to ensure that the software is safe and reliable.

    Regulatory requirements, such as FDA regulations, ISO 14971, and IEC 62304, provide guidelines for developing, maintaining, and testing medical device software. Despite the challenges associated with software testing, adopting best practices such as a risk-based approach, ensuring traceability, using automation, and collaboration can help ensure the quality and safety of medical device software.

    By following these guidelines and best practices, we can ensure that medical devices function as intended, providing accurate results and potentially saving lives, as it’s crucial to remember that behind each device is a patient whose life may depend on its functionality.

     

    Read more about the benefits from this blog: What Are the Benefits of Automated Software Testing?

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Why is software testing important in the medical device industry?

    Software testing is crucial in the medical device industry because it ensures that devices are safe to use and function as intended. It can prevent inaccurate results, misdiagnosis, and even death.

    What are the different types of software testing in the medical device industry?

    The different types of software testing in the medical device industry include functional, integration, usability, performance, and security testing.

    What are the regulatory requirements for software testing in the medical device industry?

    Regulatory requirements for software testing in the medical device industry include FDA regulations, ISO 14971, and IEC 62304, which provide guidelines for developing, maintaining, and testing medical device software.

    What are some challenges in software testing in the medical device industry?

    Some challenges in software testing in the medical device industry include the complexity of medical devices, changing regulations, and integration issues.

    What are some best practices for software testing in the medical device industry?

    Some best practices for software testing in the medical device industry include adopting a risk-based approach, ensuring traceability, using automated testing, and ensuring collaboration between different software development and testing teams.

    Get a free copy of the guidebook!

    In this book you are not going to read about futuristic robots. Instead, you will see real-time examples of how AI is transforming procurement today and tomorrow.